“CELLULAR RECEPTION SPEEDS”
NOTE - My science project was selected for inclusion at the Long Beach, California city-wide science fair on May 22, 2010.
Purpose - To find out which type of smartphone has the fastest Internet surfing speed.
Acknowledgements - I would like to thank my dad for helping me with the research and typing, my friend Emma for timing each cell phone’s Internet page download speed, and the staff of the Los Altos at&t store for directing me to several different types of smartphones to compare.
Problem - Will different types of cell phones on the same carrier and same 3G network, (in this case at&t) have different web-browsing speeds?
Research - 3G means third generation of internet and communication.
When a 2G call is made (like on at&t’s EDGE network) a line is held open for that call the whole time. With 3G, data sent across the network is divided into little “data packets,” which are reassembled in the right order at the receiving end. This means more data can be sent, and sent more efficiently and quickly than on 2G.
The Science Inside the Cell Phone
An important part of the phone speed is random access memory (RAM). This is the phone’s computer memory. There is quite a difference in the megabytes (MBs) of RAM and processor speed inside each of the phones I tested:
· BlackBerry 8310 has 32 MBs RAM, 312-MHz processor
· BlackBerry 9000 has 128 MBs of RAM, 624-MHz processor
· Apple iPhone 3G has 128 MBs of RAM, 412-MHz processor
· Apple iPhone 3GS has 256 MBs of RAM, 600-MHz processor
· Samsung Jack has 64 MBs of RAM, 528-MHz processor
· Motorola Karma has 100 MBs of RAM, does not have a CPU
Hypothesis - I think that all the cell phones will have the same internet speeds because they are all on at&t’s 3G internet network.
Experimentation - Phones
* Blackberry Curve 8310 -- on the non-3G EDGE network - chosen to compare against all the other cell phones, which are on 3G
* Blackberry Bold 9000 -- previous version of this phone, but still can be bought. The newer version is the Bold 9700
* Apple iPhone 3G -- previous version of the iPhone, but still can be bought
* Apple iPhone 3GS
* Samsung Jack --on Windows Mobile
* Motorola KarmaC. Procedure
Measure how long it takes for each phone to fully load the two web pages used for the study: CNET.com and the Los Angeles Times’ mobile site (http://m.latimes.com). We tried to also use LongBeach.gov but that site was down part of the time, so we had to switch to the more reliable and popular site from the LA Times.D. Data | Results
CNET.com LATimes.com
Blackberry 8310 24 22
Blackberry 9000 23 12
iPhone 3G 17 10
iPhone 3GS 12 6
Samsung Jack 25 9
Motorola Karma 17 9
All measurements are in seconds
E. Variables
These phones were tested inside the at&t store because they were store display phones. This means that they could have been fiddled with, and the phones could have already been used by other people to visit the websites that we chose. This means that the websites may have already been in the phone’s cache, and if so the phone remembers it and the site will load faster than it otherwise would have.
The store staff assured us that there were no 3G boosters inside the store, which would have changed the speed results we measured.
We chose two sites:
· CNET.com - probably not a site in our test phones’ cache as it is a specialty site about technology (and one of my favorite sites!)
· LATimes.com – a very popular site here in Long Beach and one that we thought would probably have a good chance of already being in the phone’s cache.
F. RAM
The Samsung Jack has less RAM than all the other 3G phones, and its measured times were the worst of all the CNET measured times.
The BlackBerry Curve 8310 has the least RAM of all the phones, and it is also the only phone that is not on 3G, so it had the slowest loading times, as expected.
G. CACHE
The load times of LATimes.com were a bit faster than those of CNET.com because LATimes was probably in each phone’s cache. The cache is a list of all the web pages that a device with Internet (computer, phone, etc.) has already been to. LATimes.com is a popular site, so it had more of a chance of being in the cache of each phone than CNET. Even though CNET is popular, it is not on the same level as LATimes. This means that LATimes load times were faster because the phone already had seen the site and knows some things about it, which makes it easier for the phone to load the website faster.
Conclusion
My hypothesis was incorrect: Even though the cell phones were all on at&t’s 3G network, they all had different web browsing speeds because each of the phones was different in its technology on the inside.
Reflections & Applications
Smartphones are not all alike. The faster phones have more RAM so they have faster web surfing speeds then phones that are cheaper and have less RAM, making them slower.
The winner of the Smartphones (the smartest) is…
The iPhone 3GS
As a big fan of Apple, this is great, and it makes sense too because of all the technology they put into their great products (and believe me, I know about Apple’s products).
Discussion - Interview with a Mobile Expert
To help me understand why all smartphones are not alike, I spoke with someone here in Long Beach, Jeb Brilliant, who reports and blogs about smartphones, and learned from my interview with him that some phones have processors that are made mostly for web browsing.
A processor is the brain of a phone, MP3 player, computer, etc. It tells the phone what to do based on the button you press. If a phone’s processor is made for web browsing, then it will have a faster web browsing speed than a phone with a normal processor.
The speeds can also vary, he explained, on how much you use the web, how long the device has been on the web, and also how many people are using the web in your same area and on the same network.
I also learned that the browsing speeds can change based on how many substations there are in your area. Substations boost the 3G speed in the area. (which I was told was not in the at&t store. This is good news.)
Another thing I learned is that phones have different places on the 3G tower. If you are in first place on the tower, your web browsing speeds will be the fastest. As more phones come on the tower, your phone’s place will go lower and lower, until it is pushed off the tower completely, and the phone has to reconnect.
Lastly, we discussed how the mobile web browser on the phone can affect the speed. Some web browsers are lightening fast like Safari on the iPhone, and others are sluggish like Palm's Blazer browser, which has trouble showing some of today's newer sites.